Shenzhen can be described as a civic startup and more specifically, an example of a charter city. On these metrics as well as several others it can be considered a success.
Until recently Nepal’s laws against drunk-driving were rarely enforced in practice. According to The Economist, things changed when Ganesh Rai assumed the reigns of Nepal’s Traffic Police. Bolstered by a scheme in which officers keep one-sixth of the fines they collect from drunk-drivers, Rai’s policy of zero tolerance appears to have significantly reduced Kathmandu’s traffic accidents, along with other alcohol-fueled crimes such as domestic violence.
The drunk-driving crackdown comes amid a broader effort to measure police performance and hold officers accountable for doing their job:
Meanwhile Mr Rai has introduced monthly evaluations, where accident statistics, fines levied and complaints received are compared among units across the city. Police appear more willing to crack down on other offences, and the numbers suggest that petty corruption has fallen.
Here again we see the introduction of basic management practices leading to what appear to be significant gains in policing effectiveness: set goals, measure performance, see what works, and hold people accountable.